Book kept me hooked but the ending was bad. Needed more details and explanations.

This book was good as far as the mystery but I didn’t love the ending. There were so many other ways this could have gone but I also don’t regret reading it because everything up until the last chapters was good. I was turning the pages like crazy trying to figure out what happened next!

Kinda good. Kinda corny. Somewhat cringy. 5.5/10 I’d say.

I loved this book so much! The way Charlie and Silas remain loyal to one another through it all, and make light of their situations. The meaning behind the story line is what I love most about it! I hope to one day see this as a sappy Rom-Com movie!

I actually find the supernatural concept quite different. Not ur normal Colleen Hoover book. And the ending, I did not expect it to be as it was. But I was intrigued to the end and finished the book. Not a mystery gripping ending that Colleen Hoover normally gives, but for me, I thought this book was somewhat had a beautiful concept to it. I really do like it.

Didn’t like the ending

I’m a fan of Colleen Hoover, and I really wanted to love this book, but it’s a miss. There is absolutely zero character development and page after page is like Groundhog Day. It’s the same thing chapter after chapter with no story progression. The ending is extremely disappointing and I just kept reading this book to get it over with. Definitely wouldn’t recommend.

Such an amazing book. The amnesia is not CoHo’s thing but she pulls it off great/wonderfully.

I wasted so many hours of my life reading this ridiculous book. The story line, I mean lack of…. I can’t say enough of how bad this book was. I love this author and I have read so many books of hers. I have no idea what happened here.

Predictable and repetitive